Touch-me-not VillageDevaki Jain THE REMEMBERED VILLAGE By M.N. Srinivas Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1976, 60.00 VOLUME II NUMBER 1 January-February 1977 The Remembered Village illustrates most
persuasively M.N. Srinivas's central concerns. First, a healthy respect for the
rural person, his life style, his knowledge. While social scientists and administrators
are constantly figuring out programmes for rural folk on the assumption that
they are 'empty vessels' into which every kind of input has to be poured, while
the educated in the universities and schools are madly mimicking urban
culture, insinuating that there is nothing in rural culture which is 'modern',
while the media portrays the peasant as some kind of docile imbecile who is cajoled
and 'educated' by the 'boot-hat' extension worker—somebody has to say, stop! What is all this about? Whom are we trying to
'develop' and on what basis of authority?
Here in Rampura, there are
strong well-developed individuals, competent managers, judges, leaders. There
is calculation before every move as amongst the most 'sophisticated' groups.
There is capacity to select and reject after considerations of
appropriateness. In fact there is a wisdom and sanity that perhaps is not there
amongst the 'change agents'.
The book should have a
salutary effect on all these categories—the alienated-from-roots students, the
media men, the administrators and the notorious 'change agents'. It should
develop in them a healthy respect for the wholesome people of the Rampuras of
India.
Another of Srinivas's
persistent concerns, in terms of the methodology of field investigation in
sociology, has been the relationship between the outsider (the observer) and
the observed. This is a live and much written about issue amongst social
anthropologists. Whereas their main preoccupation has been with the bias
question—how far the observer's presence has changed the objective situation
and therefore does not reflect the 'pure' reality—Srinivas's is more personal
agony. It is here again that his acute sensitivity, almost oversensitivity is
evident. He just cannot get over this problem of his relationship with the
villagers. Not only does he feel an outsider,
he wants to be an outsider. ‘Touch me not, nor will I touch you.’ He watches
himself watching the villagers, to a degree that is distracting. This is a
serious handicap in his style. As an illustration therefore of the agonies of
participant observation, its pitfalls and one way of keeping out of it all, the
book provides a useful lesson for prospective field ... Table of Contents >> |