The Troubled OceanStephen P. Cohen By K.R. Singh Manohar Publication, New Delhi, 1977, pp. viii 321, Rs. 60.00 VOLUME III NUMBER 1 July/August 1978 This extremely well-produced book is one of the
most thorough and comprehensive studies yet published on the politics of the
Indian Ocean, both in terms of littoral issues and the use of the sea itself.
Although one may
disagree with some of Dr. Singh’s arguments about the various powers as they
jostle for influence in the area (if one can yet call the Indian Ocean an
‘area’) his book is a valuable aid to further analysis. It is not the last word
on the subject, but it should be required reading for serious students.
Of special value are
data about the naval strength and strategies of the superpowers, the Ocean's
resources and raw material potential and the interests of various littoral and
extra-regional states in these resources. Dr. Singh has combed the published
literature, the Indian press, U.N. documents, and the extensive American
governmental material for relevant information, and has presented his findings
in a cohesive and well-written manner.
However,
one can question some of Dr. Singh’s interpretations and analyses. His basic
objective, ‘to explain the superpower and the big power rivalry in the Indian
Ocean in the context of strategy and gun-boat diplomacy,’ is never fully
realized. Dr. Singh argues that strategic ocean-going missile systems are
intimately linked to ‘the politico-military strategy’ followed by nations that
possess them, that is, the U.S., in the context of the Indian Ocean, as the
U.S.S.R. does not station its SSBM vessels in the area.
Such
a view, and his extended criticism of ‘gun-boat diplomacy’ does not do full
justice to the complex reality of superpower involvement in the region. For, in
fact, there is no public evidence that the U.S. has routinely stationed Polaris
or Poseidon submarines in the Indian Ocean (although familiarization cruises
have been announced). There are, in fact, better stations for such vessels, and
stationing a ship of any kind in the Indian Ocean means an additional transit
period of several weeks to and from the home port. Diego Garcia is not yet
capable of home-porting nuclear submarines. Finally, there is going to be a decline in at least American
ballistic missile submarines as earlier boats are scrapped and the Trident
programme has suffered major slippage.
Dr.
Singh’s strictures against gun-boat diplomacy (never really defined) are also
unpersuasive. It is in the nature of almost ... Table of Contents >> |