Roots of InequalityKaruna Ahmad INEQUALITY AMONG MEN By Andre Beteilla Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1977, pp. x 178, Rs. 50.00 VOLUME III NUMBER 1 July/August 1978 ‘The two principal political ideologies of the
present age, democracy and socialism, either singly or in various combinations
are built,’ writes Beteille, ‘on the premise of equality for all human beings.’
The philosophy underlying the concept of equality emerged mainly out of the
concern within modern nation-states with the conditions of the underprivileged
section in their societies. The first of the sources of inequality to attract
attention was economic, but subsequently race and status, or a combination of
these, were also added to the list of inequalities. Therefore, the social
scientists were led to focus attention on these indicators of inequality.
Using the Weberian
framework, Beteille has tried in this book to discuss the phenomenon of
inequality around three important dimensions, namely, status, class and power,
but he does not adhere to it rigidly. He adds the dimensions of race to his
discussion, thereby transcending the Weberian theoretical framework. This is
understandable in view of the great significance enjoyed by race as a factor in
both the national politics of certain countries and in international relations.
The author follows a
neat pattern of presentation. At the outset he distinguishes between natural
and social inequalities and leaves the former out of the purview of his
discussion. His main concern is with social inequality. After delimiting the
scope of the work thus, Beteille outlines in the first chapter the two sources
of inequality, namely, evaluation and performance. Two aspects of an individual
member or a society subjected to evaluation are quality and performance.
Quality relates to inherent or acquired traits. Some of these are birth, family
status and ethnic identity. Thus, quality and performance or achievement lead
to differentiation
and ranking of individuals and thereby to a hierarchy of statuses within a
society, whether it is traditional or modern.
The
division of labour in a society and the corresponding division of rights and
obligations also lead to differentiation of the statuses of members in a
society. Further, force, power and domination determine the positions of
members of an organization, namely, society. The situation becomes more
complicated in more complex modern societies, thereby rendering it more
difficult to ensure equality to their members.
The
twin sources of inequality, evaluation and performance, are rooted in culture
and power respectively. These two sources are responsible for order and
coherence within a society, ... Table of Contents >> |