Ala CoomaraswamyImtiaz Ahmed STRUCTURE AND COGNITION; AS¬PFCTS OF HINDU CASTE AND RITUAL By Veena Das Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1977, pp. 147, Rs. 45.00 VOLUME III NUMBER 5 March/April 1979 This is one of those books that puts a
reviewer in a dilemma. It is so promising in its design and intent that one is
tempted to characterize it as a near classic, but in its execution it leaves
one dissatisfied. Of course, to say this is not to criticize the book, but
merely to suggest the level that the book could have attained.
The book is made of four chapters, two
of which had appeared previously in the form of papers while the remaining two
are published here for the first time. The chapters entitled ‘On the Categories
Brahman, King and Sanyasi’ and ‘Of Jatis’ have been published here for the
first time. The chapters entitled ‘Concept of Space’ and ‘The Sacred and the
Profane in Hinduism’ appeared previously and have been reprinted here with
slight modification. The author's introduction traces the broad unity that runs
through the different chapters and outlines the principal theoretical thrust of
the essays considered as a whole.
As Das points out in the preface to
the book, ‘This study seeks to understand the Hindu Theories of caste and
ritual from the Hindu texts. It tries to make comprehensible the structure of
texts which until recently have been regarded as a peculiar mixture of myth and
history. I find it difficult to accept that a text is only a random
juxtaposition of ideas simply because the structure within which its author or
compiler has conceived it is not our idea of a structure. Hence the cognitive
structure of the texts has been presented here in its totality.’ This statement
is not quite as innocuous a description of the book as it sounds, but in doing
what the author says she seeks to strike at the very roots of the predominant
theoretical orientations to the study of Indian society.
The study of Indian society and this
is more often than not meant to imply Hindu society particularly, has traditionally
been carried out in terms of two distinct approaches. First of these was the
Indological approach which relied upon its construction of the social reality
on the Sanskrit or other textual sources. The second was the anthropological approach
which has usually been associated with the empirical fieldwork tradition and
relies upon observation of concrete, observable reality for the understanding
of society. Chronologically, these two approaches succeeded one ... Table of Contents >> |