A Jaundiced View of the UNSamar Sen A DANGEROUS PLACE By Daniel Patrick Moynihan Allied Publishers, New Delhi, 1979, pp. 297, Rs. 30.00 VOLUME IV NUMBER 1 July/August 1979 Moynihan is full of bounce and breeze in this 300-page
account of his stewardship of American interests in the United Nations for
eight months, July ‘75 to February '76. It pullulates with controversies, but
for an author whose background is trumpetted to be one of research and
analysis, these are surprisingly built on many wrong premises and
unsatisfactory data. In the event A Dangerous Place is not what it could have been—an intelligent America's guide
to the U.N; instead, it becomes yet another tract by a politician who has done
well and can expect to do better.
Moynihan's message is simple: if
the Third World continues to attack the USA it should instantly know that the
USSR is much worse and the developing countries are no better. They all badly
need progress and civilization and only the USA can provide them, now or in the
future. This should be done on strictly American terms and certainly not by
abusing the USA; the task is relatively easy as these countries have no real
choice except to turn to the USA and the western world which is indeed
identical to liberal democracy and civilization; anyway, Moynihan will show the
way to make the Third World behave itself. This staggeringly simple approach
naturally blinds him to the implied compliment the Third World pays in applying
‘double standards’ in judging the USA vis-à-vis the USSR. Liberal democracy is
open to criticism when it deviates from its ideal, but for dictatorships such a
fall from grace becomes irrelevant as they never can have any. Besides, are we
to enforce democracy by totalitarian methods? Moynihan does not even attempt
an answer.
About his own countrymen, his despair
is almost physically painful. ‘We are the most powerful culture in the world, I
felt we must somehow get our nerve back’; ‘For to strip our past of glory is no
great loss, but to deny it honour is devastating’. Sentences of this nature
appear with a dull monotony; nevertheless Moynihan is conscious that the
defeat in Vietnam was compounded by falsehood, corruption, treachery and
arrogance; that with licence and hypocrisy at home, and cynicism and fraud
abroad, the American ideal was unbearably strained in those dark years of
1970-75. Neither honour nor glory can exist without integrity, tolerance and a
desire to understand qualities that ... Table of Contents >> |