Tales of OldMohini Rao PANCHATANTRA (FOUR PARTS) Text by Ambika Anand ; Hindi translation, Agya Gandotra. Line drawing, Subrato Basu. Thompson Press India, 1979, pp. 46, Rs. 3.00 each THE MONKEY AND THE CROCODILE By Santosh Rae , illustrations by Anand Mohan Naik Madhuban Books, Delhi, 1979, pp. 12, Rs. 2.00 THE FOOLISH PRINCE AND THE PANCHATANTRA By Mali , illustrations by Meher Panthakay Orient Longman, New Delhi, 1979, pp. 112, Rs. 6.00 By Mathuram Boothalingam , illustrations by B.D. Sharma Publication Division, 1979, pp. 82, Rs. 6.50 VOLUME IV NUMBER 2 September/October 1979 Stories from the Panchatantra seem to be dominating recent
publications for children. They are aimed at different age groups. There are four books in the Red
and Colour series by Thomson Press, The Monkey and the Crocodile for
the very young by Vikas and The Foolish Princes and the Panchatantra, published
by Orient Longman.
Under their Red and
Colour series Thomson Press have experimented with bilingual books. Four
books have been published so far. Each has two stories, and each page carries
eight lines of the text in verse in English followed by its Hindi rendering,
also in verse. The opposite page carries a line sketch to be coloured by the
reader. These can be called 'three-in-one' books. Although this experiment has
been carried out earlier in some parts of Canada and some other countries with
considerable success, it is a novel
experiment in regard to children's books in India. Many of our children are
bilingual and even trilingual, and such books can be very helpful as pleasant
and enjoyable language teaching aids.
While the English text makes
smooth and pleasant reading, the Hindi rendering does not measure up to the
original. The language jars at places and the metre is wrong at times. The few
lines given on the second cover by way of introduction, addressed to the
readers, are in chaste Hindi—stiff, formal and cold.
The sketches are good but
sometimes too intricate. They should have been simpler, providing larger
colouring areas for the child.
A bigger size would have
been suitable for a book of this kind. The printing is neat but the cover is
not as attractive as in the case of other Thomson books In spite of the
drawbacks mentioned, the books are well devised to keep the child engaged, and
by the time he finishes with colouring the pictures, he should feel involved
with the book as he will be taking an active part in completing the book.
As with The Monkey and
the Crocodile, what is striking about this little book is the art work by
Anand Mohan Naik. The illustrations in black and white are sophisticated and
attractive, but one feels there is too much black. On some pages, where the
text and picture appear together, this impression is stronger, but the effect
is pleasant when the text and picture appear on opposite pages. However, the
artist has proved ... Table of Contents >> |