Pakistan and Nuclear DilemmaA.G. Noorani NUCLEAR PAKISTAN: ATOMIC THREAT TO SOUTH ASIA By B.P. Sinha and R.R. Subramanian Vision Books, New Delhi, 1980, pp. 164, Rs. 55.00 VOLUME V NUMBER 1 July/August 1980 One of the most difficult
topics in the field of nuclear diplomacy in South Asia is, surely, Pakistan's
nuclear programme and its objectives. Documentation is hard to come by,
information is sparse and rumour rife. Dr. Sinha and Dr. Subramanian, both of
the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses, have responded to the challenge
ably. They describe Pakistan's nuclear programme over a quarter century from
1954 to 1979, discuss its objectives, and proceed to analyse the switch-over
from the route of reprocessing of spent fuel for recovering plutonium to that
of uranium enrichment. They sum up by considering the implications of
Pakistan's programme for the region.
Although
General Zia-ul-Haq has continued the programme, contrary to Z.A. Bhutto's
accusation, it was Bhutto who, since his entry into the Cabinet of General Ayub
Khan in 1958, ‘provided new content, direction and dimensions to the nuclear
programme and policies of Pakistan.’ The opinion is fully supported by the
facts the authors mention which provide a good idea of the inception and
progress of the programme over the years.
‘Bhutto
has claimed to have commissioned the famous American architect Edward Stone to
build the Pakistan Institute of Nuclear Science and Technology (PINSTECH) at
Nelore near Islamabad, and laid its foundation stone. Bhutto negotiated with
the USA and the IAEA for the supply of enriched uranium and plutonium for use
in a 5 MW nuclear research reactor to be installed with the assistance of IAEA
at PINSTECH. Ultimately, this US-supplied “swimming pool” type research reactor
was set up in PINSTECH in 1963 under IAEA safeguards ... In October 1967 the
first batch of radio-isotope was produced in PINSTECH.
‘Shortly
after India had secured an atomic power reactor from Canada, in 1962, Bhutto,
as Minister of Industries, Natural Resources and Atomic Energy, pressed the
National Economic Council's Executive Committee to accept the proposal to
secure a nuclear power reactor from Canada. The PAEC started discussions with
Canada in 1962. In 1964 the proposal was submitted and in 1965 the agreement
was signed. Canada granted a soft loan of $ 23 million and a credit of another
$ 24 million to cover the foreign exchange cost of the plant. Japan gave a
credit of $ 3.6 million for the
turbo-generator and its installation. A number of Pakistanis were fully trained
in Canada and they returned to Pakistan in December 1968 to commission and
start the Karachi Nuclear Power Project (KANUPP) ... Table of Contents >> |