How Tales Evolve Into FilmsIpsita Sengupta ALL TIME FAVORITE BOOKS AND MOVIES AND THEIR EPIC JOURNEY (NOT GONE WITH THE WIND) By Vishwas Patil . Translated from the Marathi by Nadeem Khan Niyogi Books, New Delhi, 2015, pp. 234, Rs. 595.00 VOLUME XXXIX NUMBER 9 September 2015 As laid out in the introduction to All
Time Favorite Books and Movies and
Their Epic Journey, Patil has picked
some of his favorite stories of all time from
literature and cinema and presented rich
behind-the-scenes trivia. To these details are
added opinions which reiterate his imagination
of their ‘epic’-ness.
The first section has a set of literary works
with tales of their evolution into films, often
via theatre, Othello, Anna Karenina, Tess, A
Streetcar Named Desire, The Godfather, among
others. For example, he brings to light an
incident early in the life of Dosteovsky—of
his narrow escape from the gallows—that few
would have known. And then, he shares the
fact of the original screenplay by Syed Imtiaz
Ali Taj in 1922 that inspired Mughal-e-Azam
(this is in fact the only Indian film in this
section but that is not an important consideration
here). The next section contains some
works written about as stand-alone entities,
such as Mother India, Lagaan, The Idiot, and
others again discussed in the context of adaptations,
such as Grapes of Wrath and
Spartacus.
For the size of the book, the selection
seems quite eclectic in the geographical
spread of its objects of study. Giving a summary
of each literary or cinematic work that
are clear and concise narrations especially for
those who haven’t read the original texts,
Patil follows with facts about the creation of
the piece. The facts read more as trivia than
history—they are a set of events leading up
to the way the work turned out, and often
sporadic, almost in a coffee-table manner of
presenting. This seems all the more so because
of the way he expresses how he finds
each work.
Patil’s appreciative assessment and perspective
can be thought of this way for the
design of the book is quite ingenious. It has
animated visuals of film reels within frames
the shape of letters of the alphabet. At first
glance you may even remember tall straight
concrete buildings with lights from windows—if
seen through the alphabet frames.
Similar to the height (and often status) of
such imagined buildings, is the language of
the author for the things he appreciates—
full of superlatives and romantic descriptions
of ‘greatness’ both of the makers and the products; hyperbolic outpourings of perceptions
of grandeur that on the one hand connote
a positive passion in the arts and other
... Table of Contents >> |