![]() A Celebration Of EmpireAmar Farooqui A WINTER IN INDIA: LIGHT IMPRESSIONS OF ITS CITIES, PEOPLES AND CUSTOMS By Archibald B. Spens Routledge, New Delhi, 2014, pp. xlii 251, Rs. 750.00 VOLUME XXXIX NUMBER 10 October 2015 This is a reprint of a work originally published a century ago
(Stanley Paul, London, 1913; Dodd, Mead, New York,
1914). Although it has been published as part of the National
Archives of India (NAI) series ‘Archives in India: Historical
Reprints’, it does not seem to have had any direct or indirect connection
with the NAI. Its inclusion in the series is therefore somewhat
intriguing. Rather unhelpfully, no details are provided about
the earlier edition, and the reader is left to undertake this task with
the help of the internet or by other means. However that still leaves
unexplained the decision to include in this series a work of negligible
intrinsic worth. In his introduction to the new edition, Peter
Robb begins by confessing that he was ‘surprised
when I heard that the National Archives
of India and Routledge Publishers
wanted to reprint’ the book (p. ix). Robb,
saddled as he is with the responsibility of finding
an adequate justification for reissuing what
is ‘in many ways a disagreeable text, in its
casual assumptions of British superiority...’
(p. ix), utilizes this opportunity to reflect on
why it might be worthwhile to ‘read Spens
today?’ (p .xxix). His main argument is that
colonialism is only one among several forms
of dominance, and the independent nationstate
is not necessarily egalitarian. We need
not therefore be too critical of Spens’s celebration
of empire or his contempt, generally, for
Indians. He represents the ‘typical middle
ground’ of British attitudes towards India
during the high noon of empire.
In fact, Spens is representative of the smug
and opinionated turn-of-the-century British
traveller seeking to strengthen belief in the
historical destiny of empire by personally confirming
the inferiority of its Indian subjects. This is not a voyage of
discovery. As he concludes his journey, towards the end of March
1913, Spens seems to know almost as much about India as he did
when he disembarked at Bombay in the last week of December 1912.
He is satisfied that his ‘impressions’, as recorded in this travelogue in
the form of a diary, conform exactly to his mental image of the country
and its people. We learn very little about the places he visits, and
condescendingly talks about: Ambala, Khyber Pass, Peshawar, Agra,
Benaras, Lucknow, Kanpur, Delhi, Gwalior, Jaipur, Bombay. Except
for the Taj, which takes his breath away, he finds almost nothing
worth admiring. Spens is merely verifying for himself the ... Table of Contents >> |