![]() Question Of Ethics In Indian ScienceShiju Sam Varughese SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY AND DEVELOPMENT IN INDIA: ENCOUNTERING VALUES Edited by Rajeswari S. Raina Orient BlackSwan, Hyderabad, 2015, pp. xviii 294, Rs. 675.00 VOLUME XXXIX NUMBER 10 October 2015 Science and technology are often understood as socially disembodied
and outside the cultural domain of values, although
this view has been criticized by scholars working in the field of
Science, Technology and Society (STS) Studies since the 1970s, and
the scholarly endeavours resonated well with the civil society critique
of the epistemology of modern science and the moral universe
S&T was embedded in. In more recent times, there is strong public
scepticism on the scientific and technological advancements which
generate a spectrum of environmental and socio-economic risks. The
perception and negotiation of the risks created by science and technology
and the development pathways informed by them are often
linked to a conflict of moral values. However, this aspect of public
engagement with S&T is seldom acknowledged
in the Indian policy discourse. It is in
this context that the volume under review demands
our attention. It poses the question of
values vis-à-vis science, technology and development
in the Indian context and brings
in a variety of perspectives on the same.
In her introduction to the volume,
Rajeswari S. Raina suggests the urgency of a
critical evaluation of the values that inform
the production of scientific knowledge and
technological projects as well as the employment
of S&T in development related decision
making. On one hand, Raina suggests,
scholarly attention should be on ‘the hidden
norms or values that we take for granted,
which have been bred into our sciences, our
policy making processes, our teaching methods
or health services, our ways of working’
(p. 9). On the other hand, the chapters of the
volume are concerned about the need to seek
better ethical practices in the contexts of knowledge
production, shaping of technologies and developmental decision
making that are informed by S&T. Together these two emphases, the
volume suggests, will catalyse democratization of science in India.
From this perspective, the twelve essays in the volume are organized
around four different themes, and each section consists of three
essays. The first section (‘Mores and Moral Communities’) has essays
focusing on the moral communities of science and the values
nurtured by them—this includes scientists, engineers, technocrats,
rural public, self-help groups or the bureaucrats. Agricultural development
in India and its policy frames (A.R. Vasavi), the rare case of
expert advice extended by the Indian scientific academies during the
Bt Brinjal controversy (Gautam I. Menon and Rahul Siddharthan),
and the ... Table of Contents >> |