Development: Polemic and PerspectivesKaushik Basu WORLD ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT: 1979 AND BEYOND By Herman Kahn Vikas Publishing House, New Delhi, 1980, pp. xv 519, Rs. 125.00 VOLUME V NUMBER 2 September/October 1980 THIS is a book about the immediate past and the distant
future of mankind. It looks at the recent development experience of the world,
particularly Taiwan and South Korea, and goes on to make predictions and give
advice. But that is not all, for this is a book of disconcerting diversity. If
you are an economist wondering about the causes of inflation you may turn to
pages 294-325. If you are a mother worried about your child's upbringing, just glance through pages 474-479. And I could
go on and on.
There is nevertheless a pattern and in
particular one great divide. The first three chapters are polemical, specious
and plain boring. However from the fourth chapter the style and the tone
changes, the tempo picks up and the book becomes quite interesting.
Kahn begins by describing what he and his colleagues at the Hudson Institute call
The Great Transition, which is a period spanning the last and the next two
hundred years. The next two hundred years will neither bring about an utopia,
nor be dismal. Poverty will persist (at least during the next century) but
most people will be better off than now. All this of course assuming that there
is no ‘major nuclear war or other disaster’. As one reads on it becomes clear that not
only does Mr Herman Kahn make predictions on a variety of matters but on many
matters he also makes a variety of predictions. (This reminds me of an uncle of
mine, who had built up a considerable reputation as an astrologer by showing customers
a letter from Kennedy congratulating him for correctly predicting Kennedy's
election victory. Legend has it that he managed this only by sending a similar
letter to Nixon regarding the same election.) High-flown expressions, like ‘the
Basic long-term Multifold Trend of Western Culture’, are thoughtlessly used
and predictions on serious matters are plucked out of thin air with little
reasoning. For instance, we are told that 200 years from now the world
population is likely to be 10 billion and the gross world product 200 trillion
dollars. The latter, the author adds, is measured in 1978 prices, thereby
allaying fears that it is in 'current' prices, which would imply a prediction
of inflation over the next two hundred years! For some time there will be high
growth rates of GNP in the advanced capitalist nations (ACNs) but ... Table of Contents >> |