A Study on BondageSujata Patel PATRONAGE & EXPLOITATION CHANGING AGRARIAN RELATIONS IN SOUTH GUJARAT By Jan Breman Manohar Publishers, Delhi, 1979, pp. 287, Rs. 80.00 VOLUME V NUMBER 3 November/December 1980 When
Jan Breman's book was first published in 1974, Rural Sociology and Anthropology
was going through an introspection: community development and Panchayat Raj
had failed to bring about the peaceful revolution which would end .inequality
and' poverty. Nor did the analytical scheme of 'dominant caste' and
'Sanskritization' help in understanding why the requisite change had not taken
place. Sociologists and anthropologists of rural studies had thus begun to
examine their own theoretical and methodological assumptions which had failed
to grasp the reality in its entirety. The late sixties showed a definite shift
in the theoretical perspective in the field of rural studies. Rural studies
increasingly adopted a Marxist perspective. The focus shifted from caste
studies to the studies of peasant movements, from ‘Sanskritization' and 'westernization'
to studies of class antagonisms and class domination. This led the discipline
to widen its parameters and scope. An appreciable number of sociologists and
anthropologists turned to economics, history and politics to find new concepts to tackle
the Indian rural scene.
Jan
Breman's book came as a breath of fresh air in rural studies. The book dealt
with the relationship between the landlord and labourer; explored the bondage
relationship between two caste groups—Anavil Brahmins and Dublas in two villages
in South Gujarat; and made possible a marriage of social anthropology and
history to indicate how bondage relations were forged during pre-colonial
period and how they broke up during the late colonial period due to the impact
of the market. In a country where more than 6.1 per cent of individuals were in
bondage of one kind or other an analysis of the historical origin was much
needed Breman's book was appreciated as a seminal work. A reprint in an Indian
edition though late, is much welcome for it will make a wider audience argue
the issues he has so lucidly set down.
The book
is divided into two parts. The first part elucidates the nature of bondage in
south Gujarat which is called Halipratha. It explores the manner in which
services were extracted from the bonded labours called Hali by the landlord
Dhaniamo. The halipratha tradition was supported economically and politically
through the Jajmani system, ‘the mechanism not only for distribution of goods
and the exchange of labour but also the allocation of power and prestige’
which indicated ‘an expression of the character of the caste structure’. ... Table of Contents >> |