Eulogium on Sugar CooperativesGanesh Prashad THE POLITICS OF DEVELOPMENT: SUGAR CO-OPERATIVES IN RURAL MAHARASHTRA By B.S. Baviskar Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1980, pp. 241, Rs. 75.00 VOLUME V NUMBER 3 November/December 1980 Sugar
has produced magnates, bosses, operators and lobbies. These have held the
country to ransom. The phenomenon will make V.L. Mehta and D.R. Gadgil turn in
their graves. The former, Minister of Finance and Co-operation in post-Independence
Bombay state, had encouraged the growth of co-operative sugar factories with
great enthusiasm. The latter, a renowned economist and a zealous chairman for
the first ten years of the first post-independence co-operative sugar factory,
created an organizational framework and laid down certain practices and
conventions which became a model for subsequent factories.
Dr. B.S. Baviskar's book incorporates his research,
studies and thinking of about two decades. The study focuses on the Kisan or
Kopargaon co-operative sugar factory located in a rural area of Kopargaon
taluka in Ahmednagar district of Maharashtra.
The Sugar Enquiry Commission of 1965 found that in
Maharashtra a cooperative sugar factory contributed significantly in the
establishment of other agro-industries and in providing educational and
medical facilities in the area. It acted, so the Commission recorded, ‘as a
nucleus for social and economic development of the area around it and has
helped to develop a new class of entrepreneurs.’ Elaborating the theme,
Baviskar shows that, the Maharashtra sugar co-operatives ‘have not only modernized
agriculture in sugarcanegrowing areas and changed it from a subsistence to a
commercial proposition, but have also brought about a far-reaching social,
economic and political transformation in the rural areas’. Such is the
development brought about by the Green Revolution which, incidentally, does not
figure in the book.
The benefits of prosperity have gone mainly to the sugarcane-growers,
especially the big ones, the sugar co-operatives, the author admits, ‘have
not been able to reduce inequalities in income and wealth. If anything, such
inequalities appear to have increased’. Inequalities among sugarcane-growers
have been shown, but those between the rich and the poor are totally ignored. The plight of the underdog
does not exercise the mind of the researcher. The book devotes hardly a few
paragraphs on problems concerning workers. And there the only emphasis is on
the petty feuds of these wretched beings. In the long appendix there is a short
paragraph which provides a glimpse into the condition of the hapless workers,
though it is far from the intention of the author. An illiterate and unskilled
Harijan worker, called through the foreman to ... Table of Contents >> |