Identity: Indian StyleV. Veeraraghavan IDENTITY AND ADULTHOOD Edited by Sudhir Kakar Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1979, pp. 132, Rs. 35.00 VOLUME V NUMBER 3 November/December 1980 ‘Identity
and Adulthood’ is the product of a month-long seminar organized by the Indian
Council of Social Sciences Research in the year 1978, when experts such as Erik
Erikson, basically a psycho-analyst was called upon to lead the discussion.
Sudhir Kakar as the editor has attempted to bring together in this volume the
views of experts from different fields on the growing up process in the Indian
context.
While Professor Erikson's concept of Identity provided
the base for discussions, Sudhir Kakar argues that identity can be discussed
only in the context of personal growth and communal change. Further, he opines
that identity crisis in individual development cannot be separated from the
contemporary crisis in the historical development of his group. Identity crisis
is now accepted as an indicator of a turning point, when development either
takes a progressive or regressive direction. This crisis is seen in individual
development or in the emergence of a
new elite, or in the change that occurs in the individual who is going through
a therapeutic session, or even in the tensions of a rapid historical change.
Thus the identity is both in the individual and in his culture and it emerges
from the interplay of the psychological and social and the developmental and
historical aspects. The authors from the fields of history, psychology,
psychiatry, anthropology, sociology and literature try to conceptualize
identity and adulthood using concepts from their respective fields.
Dr. Ramanujam presents case histories of seven patients
whom he treated, and discusses the psychodynamics from Erikson's point of view.
He succeeds in demonstrating how a state of acute identity diffusion becomes
manifest at a time when the individual finds himself exposed to a combination
of experiences which demand his simultaneous commitment to physical intimacy,
and decisive occupational choice. His cases amply highlight the defects and
shortcomings in the existing child rearing practices in India. The anchor of
superstition a person holds on to, in the absence of people in the environment
who could offer a person the continuity of existence, are highlighted by him.
He thus points out the difficulty in perceiving one's identity when all
parameters are vague and diffuse. Dr. Ramanujam has strikingly brought forth
the uncertainty, dependence and the incapacity to make independent decisions
amongst many Indian youths and adults, as a consequence ... Table of Contents >> |