Pitfalls in India's Aid-DiplomacyBalraj Mehta INDIA'S AID DIPLOMACY IN THE THIRD WORLD By Dewan C. Vohra Vikas Publishing House, New Delhi, 2016, pp. IX 331, Rs. 125.00 VOLUME V NUMBER 3 November/December 1980 The
work under review was originally
a Ph. D. dissertation. It assembles a lot of material which is useful for a
study of India's economic relations with other countries after Independence,
more especially with the countries of the Third World. But it gets lost in
details and the essential thrust of the thesis is weakened in the process. The
attempt at scholarship is somewhat pedantic and lacks spontaneity.
At the
heart of Vohra's thesis is the concept of the Third World composed of countries
at different stages of development. But rating India at what has come to be
called a country at the mid-stage of its development is arguable at best. The
study of the quality and content of its economic as well as political
relations with other countries of the Third World gets misdirected and disoriented
by this characterization of India's position in the Third World. Vohra has,
therefore, presented a rather simplistic picture of continuity and growth of
India's economic relations with the Third World which is not wholly convincing.
The fact
which has not been reckoned with in depth in his study is the problem of
complementarity in trade exchanges and economic cooperation between· India and
other countries of the Third World. Indian official policy on this score has
suffered from a gross weakness. It was conceived during the first phase of its
own development and was influenced by the idea that it had to rely primarily on
inputs from the Western developed countries which have to be financed partly
by its earnings from exports to these countries and partly by foreign official
aid and foreign private investment. This exercised a strong pull on the composition
as well as direction of its trade exchanges and on the quality and content of
its economic and technical cooperation with foreign countries. The result has
been a marked lack of interest in the search for developing the right kind of
complementarity in economic relations with other countries of the Third World.
Here was a serious dichotomy between India's economic relations and its
political position as the leading light in the Third World and the non-aligned
movements.
This
dichotomy has persisted even after India has claimed to have advanced
significantly in its development
process, especially towards industrialization and modernization. This arises
from the fact that with its vaunted tenth position ... Table of Contents >> |