Seeds of EthnicityUrmila Phadnis NORTH-EAST INDIA: THE ETHNIC EXPLOSION By Nirmal Nibedon Lancers Books, New Delhi, 1981, pp. xviii 220, Rs. 95.00 VOLUME V NUMBER 5 March/April 1981 Three major
approaches underline the bourgeoning literature on Northeastern India—the
historico-political, the Marxian and the Pluralist. Emphasizing on the class
dimension of the turbulences in the various states of the region, the Marxian
perspective has noted with concern, the evolution and growth of 'little
nationalism' and nativist chauvinism. The pluralists on the other hand, have
emphasized on the perseverance of ethnic identities and the elite mobilization
of the ethnic group's sense of relative deprivation. The others, while not
getting bogged down to the ethnic/class
dimension of the North-eastern turbulence encompassing the 'seven sisters',
have attempted to explore its causes by presenting a socio-political account.
Notwithstanding the title, Nirmal Nibedon's book
falls into the third category. However, the questions which he raises in the
beginning of his study are of common concern to all interested in this region.
In a racy style characteristic of his earlier books on Nagaland and Mizoram, he
asks: ‘How did it all begin? Who planted the seeds of ethnicity and when? How
many years did it take to strike roots and grow into a gigantic tree? Who gave
the call to the people of Indo-China and peripheral Indian states making them
aware of their strong ethnic identity?’
Unlike V.IK. Sarin's study on ‘North East in
Flames’, Nibedon does not provide a state-wise account in this book. Instead,
it is a chronologically structured panoramic view of the region as a whole,
taking the readers back to more than 3000 years to identify first, 'the seeds'
of ethnicity.
The waves of migration around the Lhit Knot,
he maintains, did expose the. Brahmaputra valley in politico-cultural spheres
with the atoms providing some sort of an identity. On the other hand, the hill
tribals remained more or less insular and isolated vis-a-vis the
cultural threats from the Indo-Gangetic plain.
During the British colonial period, while the
nomenclature of 'excluded areas' more or less meant their non-control therein
and therefore a virtually uninterrupted continuation of traditional tribal
social structures, the pattern of migration from the west, in other areas was
far more purposive. It is not without significance that these migrants were
described by different names by the indigenous people which had more than
often a perjurative connotation: they were viewed as 'coolies, small-time economic
exploiters and lackeys of British imperialism. As for Assam in particu... Table of Contents >> |