Indian Perspective on AfghanistanRita Manchanda AFGHANISTAN IN CRISIS Edited by K.P. Misra Vikas Publishing House, New Delhi, 1981, pp. 150, Rs. 75.00 VOLUME V NUMBER 5 March/April 1981 Confronted
with a host of· books on Afghanistan the overwhelmed reader needs to have good
reason not to consign to unread oblivion yet another work on the subject. What
distinguishes this selection of essays is their analytical presentation of an
Indian perspective on the Afghan crisis and its implications for the region and
the international system. With India having adopted a singular position on the
Afghan question, the reflections of Indian academics on the various aspects of
the crisis holds special interest.
However, it is regrettable that in this selection, there
is no sustained analysis of 'Iran and the Afghan crisis'. The security thesis
that interprets the Soviet intervention of December 1979 as designed to
preempt imminent US military action in Iran, finds no mention in either Agwani
or Damodaran's dismissal of the security dimension underlying the Soviet move.
K. Bahadur in 'Pakistan's policy towards Afghanistan’ touches upon the
implications of US military intervention in Iran, aimed ultimately at restoring
the monarchy, in the wake of the hostage crisis, which he argues, left the
Soviets with no other option than to intervene to save the revolutionary regime
and protect their own security. The focus of the security concern, however,
remains Afghanistan and not Iran, as in the preemptive thesis.
Still on the Iranian connection, a lacunae is again
conspicuous in the neglect of the role of Iran in the April 1978 Saur
Revolution. Srivastava's assertion in 'The US and Recent Developments in
Afghanistan', that the increasing close ties between Afghanistan and Pakistan/Iran,
the two staunchest allies of the US, did untold damage to Daoud's relations
with the Soviets, is wide off the mark. Unable to rid himself of the outdated
bipolar perspective, he accentuates the US-SU opposition, failing to pursue the
much more significant argument of the domestic backlash against the enormous
increase in Iranian influence. In the wake of the 1977 Pakistan-Afghanistan
accord under Iranian auspices, not only did Iranian influence phenomenally expand
but there was also the spawning of inter-linkages, it is reported, between the
Iranian intelligence service SAVAK and its Afghan counterpart. The Shah, it is
believed, was no stranger to the assassination of the editor Khaiber or the arrests
of Taraki and other Communist leaders, that precipitated the Saur revolution.
Agwani, in 'The Saur Revolution and After' also eschews
all consideration of the Iranian role in what is otherwise a very balanced
presentation ... Table of Contents >> |