So Near And Yet So FarV. Suryanarayan By Navrekha Sharma and Baladas Ghoshal Market Asia, Singapore , Research Asia, South Asia Research Series, 2014, pp. 306, price not mentioned. VOLUME XL NUMBER 9 September 2016 Why is the United States the most
powerful country in the world
today? I always pose this question
to students in my inaugural lecture on contemporary
Southeast Asia. Students provide
several answers. The United States is the
most powerful country in the world; it has
vast economic resources; technologically it
is the most advanced country, etc. While the
above answers contain elements of truth, I
clinch the issue by stating that the United
States is the first country in the world to
realize that knowledge is power. American
Universities—Harvard, Yale, Columbia,
MIT to name some—attract the best talents
from countries across the world and they set
in motion concepts and ideas which we in
the rest of the world blindly accept.
One such concept which originated in
the early 1950s was the division of our part
of the world into South Asia and Southeast
Asia. The Indian School of International
Studies, started in 1955, thanks to the initiative
taken by Pandit Hriday Nath Kunzru
and Professor A. Appadorai accepted this
division. It is necessary to remind ourselves
that Indian historians like R.C. Majumdar,
Nilakanta Sastri, H.B. Sarkar and B.R.
Chatterjee used the term Southeast Asia to
cover both South Asia and Southeast Asia.
By accepting the American premise that
South and Southeast Asia are two distinct
geographical entities, countries which are
close to us geographically and culturally became
intellectually distant. Few people in
India realize the fact that the distance between
Indira Point and Pu Breush in Northwest
Sumatra is only 92 nautical miles, less
than the distance between Chennai and
Tirupati. Similarly the distance between
Indira Point and the nearest place in Thailand
is less than the distance between
Chennai and Madurai.
In its Annual Report the Ministry of
External Affairs refers to SAARC countries as
immediate neighbourhood and countries in
Southeast Asia as extended neighbourhood.
How much nearer should Thailand and Indonesia
be to India for the Mandarins in the
South Bloc to realize that Thailand and Indonesia
are part of our immediate
neighbourhood and not extended
neighbourhood?
Navrekha Sharma and Baladas Ghoshal
are eminently qualified to analyse the twists
and turns in India-Indonesia relations. A
diplomat, Navrekha had two assignments in
Indonesia, first as Minister—Counsellor
(1993–96) and second as Ambassador
(2006–08). Baladas Ghoshal has specialized
in Southeast Asian Studies; his doctoral dissertation
was on Guided Democracy in Indonesia;
he is fluent in Bahasa Indonesia and,
... Table of Contents >> |