New Login   

Shattering the Myth of Homogeneity

Luv Puri

By Yoginder Sikand
Rupa, New Delhi, 2011, pp. 196, Rs.595.00


'We were told that Muslims in Kashmir are not allowed to practice their religion and Islam is in danger. This is what moved me to come here and fight Indian troops', said 17-year-old Lashkar activist Mohammad Abdullah nervously in police custody in August 2002. Abdullah, a Seraki speaking resident of the Multan area of south western Pakistan had massacred twenty-nine dozen Hindu slum dwellers including 14 children on the outskirts of Jammu, the winter capital of J&K, on the evening of 13 July 2002 . Mohammad Abdullah is not the only Pakistani national to have invoked solidarity with Muslims of Jammu and Kashmir as a prime motivating factor to join terrorist ranks in the region. Ironically, the person who tipped off the police about Abdullah was a Jammu and Kashmir Muslim resident in whose house the militants tried to take shelter after carrying out the massacre. The problem in Jammu and Kashmir is often seen as a conflict between Muslims and Hindus. However internally, it is the diversity within the Muslim community of the region that is pivotal in understanding some of the critical aspects of the region's political history. In 1947, when the Muslim leadership of Kashmir Valley under Sheikh Abdullah supported the state's accession with India, the Muslim leadership of Jammu supported the Dogra Maharaja and his desire for an independent state. For the last six-decades scholarship on Jammu and Kashmir has virtually ignored the divergence within the Muslim community in terms of political and social outlook. A myth of homogeneity has been re-cycled again and again thus ignoring the more complex world of the region's politics. This divergence has been a key determinant of the region's political developments for more than six-decades. Sikand in this latest work Religion,Inter-Community Relations and Kashmir Conflict brings to light some aspects of the divergence. One of the strengths of the book is with respect to Sikand's narrative on various strands of theological interpretations within Islam. Sikand says, 'Islam like any other religion has been interpreted diversely' and even the Muslim majority region of Jammu and Kashmir does not buck this trend'. Through his work, Sikand implicitly challenges the binary notions of Muslim community which slots them into the categories of moderates and hardliners in the present context. For example, his chapter on 'Politics and the Tabligi: Views from Doda' is an excellent exposition of how Jamaat-e-Islami and Tablighi Jamaat perceive each other which many will ...

Table of Contents >>
Please or to Read Entire Article

Free Access Online 12 Back Issues
with 1 year's subscription
Archive (1976-2011)
under construction.